The short version
- Couples in a September 2026 thread found €3,000 was the usual starting quote for a band. Others reported paying about €2,000 to €3,500, often with a DJ included.
- DJ-only couples mostly say the floor was full and they have no regrets. Band fans say nothing beats a good live band.
- Your crowd decides it. Older guests and rural crowds who jive or waltz tend to expect a band.
- The popular middle options: a DJ with a saxophone player, or a band that hands over to a DJ.
- See any band play before you book, and ask whether the line-up you saw is the one you'll get.
What people say they paid for a band
The most useful recent thread is a “pulse check” from September 2026. The poster, planning a Thursday in August in the west, had sent more than ten enquiries to bands around the country and had only one quote under €3,000. They had expected €2,000 to €2,500 and asked if they were out of touch (thread). Replies from people who had booked:
| What they booked | Price |
|---|---|
| Band and DJ, Saturday in October 2023 | €3,200 |
| Band and DJ, wedding in 2025 | €3,500 |
| Band and DJ, wedding in June 2026 | €2,200 |
| Band, booked in 2026 | just over €2,000 |
| Evening band and DJ, midlands | €2,500 |
| Ceremony and drinks reception band, midlands | €1,900 |
One commenter added €150 for a brass player, and another made the obvious point that very little in the country costs what it did two years ago. In r/irishpersonalfinance, a musician who said they had played a lot of weddings put the average at about €2,000 to €2,500, maybe €3,000 including ceremony music, while the couple who started that thread had budgeted €5,000 for music for the whole day, DJ included (thread). When someone in an older thread asked for a range, the answer was €2,000 to €5,000 (thread).
Two things push the price up that Reddit mentions: peak dates (the poster above thought a Thursday in August still counted) and travel, since bands based far from the venue will usually charge for it (thread).
Band or DJ: the actual argument
Couples who skipped the band mostly sound happy with it. In a thread from a couple regretting their decision to go DJ only, the replies were reassuring: several said they had a DJ all night and the floor was full, and one who had a band said they wished they hadn't bothered (thread). The case for the DJ, in one line:
“A good DJ can adapt to suit the crowd whereas a band will just stick to their list.”
The other side is just as sure of itself. In a thread about a 70-guest wedding, the second most upvoted reply came from someone who said they did 17 years of hotel management:
“The atmosphere of a good live band is unparalleled.”
One couple said they went to a wedding with only a DJ and both missed the live band so much that it became the one thing they would not cut from their own (thread). And the line from the same thread that sums up the risk on both sides:
“If you have a weak band, they’re still a band, there’s a vibe.”
The same commenter's next line was that a bad DJ leaves you with nothing, which is the real warning. A DJ is the cheaper option only if it is a good one.
Who your guests are decides it
The most practical replies were about the crowd rather than the music. One commenter said that if you are in a big jiving area, such as the border counties or somewhere very rural, or have an older guest list who like to waltz, a band would be expected; if your crowd is not into that, a DJ is fine (thread). Another, in the r/ireland thread, reminded the groomsman booking the band not to forget a waltz for the grannies (thread).
The rest of the advice runs the same way:
- One couple who wanted R&B, Afrobeats and hip hop found a DJ was the realistic option for those styles.
- For a smaller wedding with lots of children, people suggested a singer with a guitar, an acoustic set before the DJ, or a band that can throw in a Disney song or two.
- Know your audience and check the setlist. A band that only plays recent music won't suit a room with a lot of guests over 60.
- Booking only for your own taste can backfire if your guests don't share it.
Those points come from four threads (thread) (thread) (thread) (thread), and the last one from a guest who still remembers a bad country and western band from 1985.
The middle options people actually booked
- DJ and saxophone. The most mentioned alternative to a band, from a DJ and sax for a 100-guest wedding (“one of the best decisions we made”) to a solo sax player who worked alongside the DJ. A few people were not fans of the sax.
- Band, then DJ. Lots of bands supply a DJ who keeps going while the others pack up. One commenter's caution: if the day runs late, the band and DJ sets can both end up squeezed.
- A playlist and a hired sound system. The top reply in the alternatives thread said it went down better than most band gigs, helped by a friend acting as MC. Others had guests add songs to a shared playlist. The catch: someone sober has to mind it, and one guest said a playlist-only wedding they attended had very little dancing.
- Live music earlier in the day. Couples booked a string trio or a band for the ceremony and drinks reception, and a DJ for the night.
Sources for this section: (thread) (thread) (thread) (thread). If you go this way, look at ceremony music and singers and drinks reception music.
How Redditors pick a band
The single most repeated piece of advice is to see them play. A good band won't mind you looking in at a gig or a wedding for a few minutes, many run showcases, and one couple said their band let them book and get the deposit back if they didn't like the showcase (thread) (thread). The rest of the checklist:
- Watch the videos guests have tagged the band in on Instagram, not just the band's own, to see how the crowd reacts.
- Ask whether you'll get the line-up you saw. Commenters warned that some larger acts are a roster of musicians under one name, and singers can change before your date.
- Ask about the first dance. One poster was put off a band whose FAQ said it won't learn a new song in busy months.
- Ask about travel and accommodation charges if the band is based far from the venue.
- Ask your venue for its list of bands, and search the Help I'm Getting Married Facebook group for reviews.
Those points are from (thread) (thread) (thread) (thread). Not everyone thinks it matters much:
“They all play the same middle of the road setlist, pick the cheapest and have a nicer honeymoon.”
The r/ireland thread disagreed, and put it more bluntly: “They can make or break the wedding.” (thread)
Where Reddit is right, and where it's thin
The threads are good on the decision itself: match the music to your guests, see the act live, and don't book a cheap DJ to save money. They are weaker on prices, which are self-reported, range across several years and rarely say how many musicians or hours were included. Before you compare quotes, ask each band for the number of players, the hours of live music, whether a DJ is included and what travel costs.
And one practical tip from the threads that will save you time: when you search for “wedding bands Ireland”, you will get a lot of rings (thread). Our pages for wedding bands and wedding DJs are only the musical kind.
Still choosing the venue? Read what Reddit says about wedding venues in Ireland.